Hypermobility vs Ehlers-Danlos: What's the Difference?
Joint hypermobility is a trait, HSD is that trait with symptoms, and hEDS is one of 13 EDS types, diagnosed on the 2017 criteria with no gene test.

Photo: Maria Kovalets / Unsplash
I score 7 out of 9 on the Beighton score, the traditional check for loose joints, two points past the adult cut-off of 5. I get points for my knees and back but not my elbows, and my hands are loose at the last finger joint, which isn't one of the nine points. Even so, my little fingers are about the only joints that give me much pain, and they weren't great fingers for my years as a massage therapist. If you can fold in half and you've wondered whether that's a problem or has anything to do with your pain, that's a fair thing to wonder about.
Joint hypermobility is a trait that becomes hypermobility spectrum disorder (HSD) once it causes symptoms. Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome (hEDS) is one of 13 EDS types, diagnosed on 2017 criteria because it has no gene test yet. So I can score 7 with so little pain, and working out which of these you have takes more than a score. I tend to think of the label as the second question, since whichever fits, steadying loose joints starts with your muscles.
Can you be very flexible and have nothing wrong?
Yes, you can. Joint hypermobility doesn't look the same from one person to the next. You might be loosest in your knees and back, like I am, or in different joints altogether, and the looseness might hurt a lot or barely bother you.
Marco Castori and colleagues put together a framework in 2017 for sorting out joint hypermobility and the conditions related to it. They pointed out that loose joints are a feature of many other disorders too, both genetic and acquired, and they described different types of joint hypermobility and the problems in the muscles and joints that can follow from it. For people whose loose joints cause symptoms but don't fit any other syndrome with joint hypermobility, they proposed the label hypermobility spectrum disorders.
In other words, loose joints become a disorder once they start causing problems, and until then, with no other syndrome behind them, they're a trait. Whether loose joints with symptoms are HSD or hEDS depends on more than the joints, because EDS is a disorder of connective tissue, the material that holds the body's structures together.
Why does an hEDS assessment look past your joints?
Fransiska Malfait and the International EDS Consortium published a new classification of the Ehlers-Danlos syndromes in 2017. They described the syndromes as inherited connective tissue disorders marked by loose joints, stretchy skin and fragile tissues, so a clinician assessing hEDS looks at your skin and other tissues as well as at how far your joints bend. The consortium recognized 13 types. For every type except hEDS, a definite diagnosis relies on finding the gene variant that causes it, and hEDS has no such test yet. The consortium also rewrote the clinical criteria for hEDS to separate it more clearly from other conditions with loose joints.
The Ehlers-Danlos Society's hEDS diagnostic checklist lists those full criteria, and a diagnosis needs all three of its parts together. Your joints have to be loose across the body, which the clinician checks with the Beighton score, at 5 or more out of 9 up to age 50 and 4 or more after 50. You also need at least two of three things beyond the joints, which are features of your skin and connective tissue, a close relative with hEDS, and musculoskeletal problems like chronic pain or repeated dislocations. On top of that, the clinician has to rule out other explanations, including the other EDS types and other connective tissue conditions.
HSD is the label when loose joints cause symptoms without meeting all three parts or fitting another syndrome. Looking through the checklist ahead of time is a good way to see what an assessment will cover, and the clinician who examines you is the one who scores it. Since the whole checklist starts from the Beighton score, the research behind that score comes next.
How well does the Beighton score pick up loose joints?
The Beighton score is a 9-point check. You get a point for each little finger, thumb, elbow and knee that bends further than usual, and a ninth point for putting both palms flat on the floor with your knees straight. For the little finger, the clinician is looking for a bend back to 90 degrees or more.
Birgit Juul-Kristensen and colleagues gathered the studies of clinical tests for generalized joint hypermobility, meaning loose joints across the whole body, and rated how well each study was done. Most of those studies used the Beighton score, so how well does it hold up? Turns out, the reviewers rated every one of the studies fair or poor in quality, and for the Beighton score most of the reliability studies showed limited positive to conflicting evidence, which means you might not get the same score every time you're checked. They still recommended it for clinical use, with 5 out of 9 as the adult cut-off, counting how flexible you used to be as well as how flexible you are now. That's a little over half the points, and for children they recommended at least 6 out of 9.
Keep in mind, not everybody is hypermobile in the joints the Beighton score covers. If your loosest joints are small ones, like the end joints of your fingers, you can have symptoms there rather than in the bigger joints and still score low. So a score is one part of the assessment, and whatever it comes to, steadying the joints themselves starts with the muscles around them.
Whatever the label, stability around loose joints starts with your muscles
Raoul Engelbert and colleagues wrote a 2017 physical therapy guideline for hEDS and for joint hypermobility syndrome, an older label from before the 2017 criteria. They described physical therapy as central to managing hypermobility-related disorders within a team of different specialists, on treatment research they judged limited in size and quality. The way I look at it, the best thing you can do as a hypermobile person is build stability around your joints by training the muscles around them, and you're a hypermobile person whichever label you leave the assessment with. I'm not a physical therapist, and this is more from personal experience, but locking a joint to hold yourself steady takes much less work than engaging the muscles around it, and that habit isn't the healthiest one long term.
Those of us with hypermobility are experts at getting around the muscle an exercise is meant to train.
Bypassing that muscle has been my experience my entire life. When you're learning to stabilize with your muscles, you might need more conscious cues at first, like being told you should feel an exercise in your butt instead of your thigh, or in your lats instead of all the tiny muscles in your arm.
In practice, hEDS happens together with postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome (POTS) and mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS) so commonly that clinicians refer to the three as a triad. In POTS, your heart rate climbs too far when you stand up, and in MCAS, mast cells, a kind of immune cell, release their chemicals too easily. If you've seen very different numbers for how common MCAS is alongside POTS and hEDS, why the MCAS estimates disagree so much goes through how the criteria a study uses change the count. Anything you notice beyond your joints can go into the assessment along with the joints themselves.
Which joints do you lock to hold yourself steady?
A geneticist, a rheumatologist or another clinician experienced with hypermobility can make the assessment, and your clinician can help you sort out whether you have HSD, hEDS or hypermobility with no disorder at all. What you've noticed about how you hold yourself steady gives them more to go on than a single score, and some people find it helps to jot these down before the visit.
- Which joints feel loose or unstable, and which ones you find yourself locking to hold steady, including small ones like the end joints of your fingers, which aren't part of the Beighton score. Any dislocations or subluxations go here too. Subluxation means a partial dislocation, where the joint slips out and then goes back in.
- Which joints hurt, and whether they're the same ones you lock.
- Any physical therapy you've had, and whether anyone told you where you should feel each exercise.
- How flexible you were as a child, since the adult cut-off counts how flexible you used to be. If you can't remember, don't sweat it, because a parent or older sibling might. Relatives who are very flexible or have an EDS diagnosis go here too, along with any relative who had an artery or organ rupture, since family history is part of how vascular EDS, an uncommon type that can cause those ruptures, is first recognized.
- Whether your skin is stretchy or seems fragile, since EDS involves the skin as well as the joints.
Dizziness when you stand, gut trouble and tiredness can go in your notes as well. If gut trouble is one of them, why gut problems are so common in hEDS covers connective tissue and how food moves through the gut. For tiredness, why hypermobility can leave you so tired goes through how holding loose joints steady can take extra muscle work.
I go much further into all of this in Hypermobility, Reconsidered, a course opening Friday, November 20. The chronic fatigue hub has the related posts in the meantime.
However the assessment comes out, the muscles around your joints are something you and a physical therapist who knows hypermobility can work on, and you can take this one step at a time. If physical therapy is part of your plan, I'd suggest looking for a therapist who can tell you where you're supposed to feel each exercise. I hope this helps you go into that assessment knowing what's being checked and why. If chronic fatigue is part of your picture, ME/CFS, Reconsidered is an upcoming course on ME/CFS, post-viral fatigue, and pacing. You can join The Weekly Well, our free newsletter, to hear when the course opens.
FAQ
What is Ehlers-Danlos syndrome?
The Ehlers-Danlos syndromes are a group of inherited connective tissue disorders marked by joint hypermobility, stretchy skin and fragile tissues. The International EDS Consortium's 2017 classification recognizes 13 types. For every type except hypermobile EDS, a definite diagnosis relies on finding the gene variant that causes it.
Is there a genetic test for hEDS?
Not yet. In the 2017 international classification, hypermobile EDS is the only one of the 13 types whose definite diagnosis doesn't rely on finding a causative gene variant. Clinicians diagnose it on its clinical criteria instead, which the Ehlers-Danlos Society publishes as a checklist.
What is vascular Ehlers-Danlos syndrome?
Vascular EDS (vEDS) is an uncommon type, estimated at 1 in 50,000 to 1 in 200,000 people, so a city of 200,000 might have somewhere between one and four people with it. It's caused by variants in the COL3A1 gene, and it can cause tears or ruptures of arteries and the bowel, and of the uterus in pregnancy. In a 2017 international consensus, Peter Byers and colleagues recommended identifying the COL3A1 variant before making the diagnosis, with care from a team of specialists who can manage those complications. Family history is part of how vEDS is first recognized, so a relative who had an artery or organ rupture is something to tell your clinician about.
Can you be hypermobile with a low Beighton score?
Yes, it's possible. The Beighton score has points for the little fingers, thumbs, elbows, knees and a forward bend, and not everybody is hypermobile in those joints. If your loosest joints are small ones outside the score, such as the end joints of the fingers, you can still score low.
Does the Beighton score cut-off change with age?
It can, according to a 2026 meta-analysis in which Louise Tofts and colleagues combined Beighton scores from 46 studies of about 23,000 adults in the general population. For screening, meaning a first check for loose joints across the body, they suggested 6 or more from 18 to 25, 5 or more from 26 to 65, and 4 or more over 65, so a score of 5 is over the line at 30 and under it at 20. The hEDS checklist uses 5 or more up to age 50 and 4 or more after 50, and a 2017 review of hypermobility tests recommended at least 6 out of 9 for children. If your score sits near one of these lines, asking which cut-off your clinician used can explain a result that surprised you.
Is hypermobility a disability?
It can be, depending on how much it limits your daily life. A hypermobile person can have no limits from it at all, while someone with HSD or hEDS can have pain or injuries that make work and daily tasks harder. Whether that counts as a disability depends on the rules where you live, more than on which diagnosis you have.
References
- 1.
- 2.
- 3.
- 4.
- 5.
- 6.




